July 19, 2024
Image default

Active vs Passive funds – Which is a better investment option 

Investing in mutual funds is far easier than buying individual stocks. They increase diversity, reduce risk, and require less active monitoring of share price fluctuations.

However, this is a wide view of index fund vs mutual fund, and to be really candid, it is inadequate. When it comes to mutual funds, you will have a wealth of possibilities. Choosing the most suited system from among them requires a higher degree of comprehension.

Before going into the finer points of mutual funds, it’s vital to grasp their two main classifications: index fund vs mutual fund.

While the former may provide more benefits, the latter involves less risk. Index funds are a kind of passively managed mutual fund. Index funds and mutual funds are fundamentally distinct in their investment objectives, price structure, and management style.

Passive funds invest in market capitalization and are not actively managed by the fund manager. They replicate the indexes produced by the NSE or BSE. On the other hand, active funds invest in businesses based on their research and the opinions of their research team and fund management. These funds may invest in firms with a more significant potential for growth than those with a large market capitalization alone.

Active funds have the potential to earn more significant returns than the benchmark index. Still, they also can earn lower returns if the fund manager makes poor stock selection decisions. At the same time, passive funds guarantee investors market-linked returns. For instance, if the NIFTY 50 index returns 12% pa over the following five years, the index fund will earn 12% pa. 

Check out Navi’s blog about index fund vs mutual fund to know more.

Which is the Most Prudent Investment?

Numerous businesses continue to have room to improve efficiency and performance across multiple industries. Active funds allow you to invest in such firms.

Over the long run, a mix of active and passive funds may perform effectively. Investors new to mutual fund investing may allocate a more significant portion of their portfolio to passive funds. Investors with a moderate to high tolerance for risk can give 15-20% to these funds and the remainder to active funds.

Investors interested in passive funds might investigate NIFTY, SENSEX, or NIFTY Next 50. You may check at Large & Mid Cap and Flexi Cap funds in the active fund area.

Mutual Funds: Active vs Passive

Active mutual funds are managed actively by fund managers. These managers must make proactive judgments on whether to purchase or sell a specific stock based on market circumstances and the company’s intrinsic characteristics. The fund manager’s objective of an active mutual fund is to create returns that outperform the benchmark index.

For instance, the fund manager of a large-cap active mutual fund (which tracks the NIFTY50 index as a benchmark index) would seek to outperform the NIFTY50 index in terms of returns.

Analysts and the research team assist the fund management in conducting research and monitoring the performance of the firms in which investments are made. Because the individuals engaged are highly compensated, this adds to fund management costs, resulting in significantly higher expense ratios for actively managed funds. As a result, the fund manager must earn more significant returns to justify the fund’s increased cost ratio, according to Garg.

However, fund managers do not actively trade equities with passive funds, and these products are referred to as index funds. The investment is made in the index’s constituent equities in the same proportion as the index. The aim is to get a return that is comparable to the index.

The expenditures associated with passive fund managers are often cheaper than those associated with active funds since no specialist crew must follow the market. These funds earn market-correlated returns.


Individuals still debating on index fund vs mutual fund must understand that their decision should be based on their financial situation and ambitions. While index funds have historically outperformed actively managed funds, there are some very efficient active fund managers. However, novice investors who are just getting started with mutual fund investing may want to explore investing in index funds.